PARKS & RECREATION BOARD 2014/05/20 Packet
PARKS AND RECREATION BOARD MEETING
TUESDAY, MAY 20, 2014
6:30PM at CITY HALL
LAKE FOREST, ILLINOIS
AGENDA
I. CALL TO ORDER & ROLL CALL
Steve Hill, Chairman _____Charlie Kohlmeyer
David Brush _____Curt Volkmann
Dan Jasica _____Paul “Skoo” Walker
*Sondra Douglass, new board member will begin her term June 17, 2014
II. APPOVAL OF MINUTES
A. Approval of the minutes of the March 18, 2014 Parks and Recreation
Board Meeting
B. April 15, 2014 COTW meeting was cancelled
III. OPPORTUNITY FOR CITIZENS TO ADDRESS THE PARKS AND RECREATION BOARD ON
NON-AGENDA ITEMS
IV. FOREST PARK PROJECT UPDATE—Presented by Ralph Gesualdo, Peter Cherry &
Augie Ziccarelli
V. SPOTLIGHT: 2014 FOREST PARK BEACH AND BOATING BASIN—Presented by Jeff
Wait, Superintendent of Special Facilities
VI. APPROVAL OF CONTRACTS
A. Approval of Fitness Center Weight Equipment Contract—Presented by
Jason Busdeker, Fitness Center Manager
VII. EVERETT TOT LOT PLAYGROUND PROPOSED DESIGN OPTIONS—Presented by Chuck
Myers, Superintendent of Parks and Forestry
VIII. CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECT UPDATE—Presented by Chuck Myers,
Superintendent of Parks and Forestry
IX. DIRECTOR’S REPORT
X. COMMENTS BY BOARD MEMBERS
XI. ADJOURNMENT
The City of Lake Forest
Parks and Recreation Board
Meeting Minutes
March 18, 2014
I. Call to Order
The Parks and Recreation Board Meeting was called to order by Chairman Curt Volkmann at
6:30p.m. The following were present:
Board Members: Mr. David Brush
Mr. Dan Jasica
Mr. Charlie Kohlmeyer
Mr. Curt Volkmann, Chairman
Mr. Skoo Walker
Staff: Ms. Mary Van Arsdale, Director of Parks and Recreation
Mr. Chuck Myers, Superintendent of Parks, Forestry & Cemetery
Ms. Sally Swarthout, Superintendent of Recreation
Mr. Anthony Anaszewicz, Athletics Program Manager
Mr. Jason Busdeker, Fitness Center Manager
Mr. Rob Carmichael, Wildlife Discovery Center Curator
Mr. Peter Gordon, City Forester
Mr. Joe Mobile, Program Manager
Mr. Rich Paulsen, Parks Supervisor
Ms. Tricia Schwall, Administrative Assistant
Special Guests: Mr. Mike Adelman, Alderman
II. Approval of Minutes
The meeting minutes of the November 19, 2013 Park & Recreation Board meeting were presented.
Board Member Kohlmeyer moved for approval of the minutes and Board Member Jasica
seconded. The Board meeting minutes of the November 19, 2013 meeting were then unanimously
approved.
The meeting minutes of the December 17, 2013 Committee of the Whole Park & Recreation Board
meeting were presented.
Board Member Kohlmeyer moved for approval of the minutes and Board Member Jasica
seconded. The Board meeting minutes of the December 17, 2013 meeting were then unanimously
approved.
The meeting minutes of the February 18, 2014 Committee of the Whole Park & Recreation Board
meeting were presented.
Board Member Kohlmeyer moved for approval of the minutes and Board Member Jasica
seconded. The Board meeting minutes of the February 18, 2014 meeting were then unanimously
approved.
III. Opportunities for the Public to Address the Board on Items not Listed on the Agenda
There were no comments.
IV. Spotlight: Summer Camps 2014
Rob Carmichael, Wildlife Discovery Curator gave an overview of the Summer Camps that are
available through the Parks & Recreation Department. He shared the different types of camps that
are offered and some of the benefits that come from attending camps. He also talked about the
Camp Preview Day that was held at Deerpath Middle School and Daniel Write Junior High in
February along with the Camp Focus Feedback that was gathered from residents to help make
changes to the camp programs. He also gave a brief overview of the Counselor in Training program
that is offered through the Rec Center, participation in the camps to date and a financial overview
from the past 2 summers.
V. Approval of Parks & Recreation Memorial Policy
Superintendent Myers presented the Memorial Tree and Bench Policy with the board. He noted
that several changes had been made to the policy following the suggestions previously made by
board members. Board Member Brush asked about the fee structure. Superintendent Myers
explained the fees. Board Chairman Volkmann asked where the benches and trees would go in the
parks. Superintendent Myers said it would be up to the Parks & Forestry sections to make the
determination and that they are planning on putting maps in place for each area and map out where
they would like the benches/trees to go. Board Member Jasica asked if the intent was to make
these maps available to the public. Superintendent Myers answered yes. Board Member Jasica
shared a concern with the wording of how the City would contact the donor if the donation had
reached the end of its useful life. Superintendent Myers said that they would make necessary
changes to the language of those areas. This document will be review periodically.
Requested Action: Approval of the Memorial Tree and Bench Policy.
A motion was made by Board Member Jasica to approve the Memorial Tree and Bench Policy with
changes to the wording of how the City will contact donor regarding the end of the useful life of
the donation. The motion was seconded by Board Member Brush. The motion passed.
VI. Approval of Contracts
A. McClory Bike Trail/Deerpath Park Walking Path
Superintendent Myers explained the background of the McClory Bike Path Improvement
Project. He shared that this project is part of the City’s Public Works Road Overlay Program.
He also discussed the Deerpath Trail Re-Configuration and Resurfacing Project which is part
of the Capital Improvement Plan and went out to bid with another Public Works project that
involves resurfacing at two City schools which includes Deerpath School. By adding the trail
work to the Public Works project at the schools it will provide better pricing for the smaller
trail project. A short discussion followed regarding the participation of the school in paying
for some of the resurfacing of the trail and some of the other projects the City has at various
schools throughout the City.
B. Approval of Northcroft Park and Deerpath Park Tennis Court Contract
Superintendent Myers presented the contract for Northcroft and Deerpath park tennis court
resurfacing and fence replacement. The eight courts would be resurfaced, the fence at
Northcroft would be totally replaced and the fence at Deerpath would have its mesh
replaced. He shared that the bids include power washing all courts, filling smaller cracks
with crack filler or larger cracks with Armor Crack patching material, grinding of surface to
level, filling all low spots that hold water, and multiple applications of Colorguard surfacing
compound. The total amount requested also includes a new practice board at Northcroft
and a 5% contingency for the entire project. A short conversation followed regarding cost
sharing with Deerpath School.
Requested Action: Approval to enter into a contract with 10-S Court Solutions for
resurfacing tennis courts and replacing fence at Northcroft and Deerpath Parks. Staff also
seeks approval of an additional $9,640 for the practice wall replacement at Northcroft and
the 5% contingency for a grand total of $97,440.
A motion was made by Board Member Walker to approve the contract with 10-S Court
Solutions for the resurfacing of eight tennis courts and replacement of fence at Northcroft
and Deerpath parks including Armor Crack Repair for a total of $87,800. And for an
additional $9,640 for the practice wall replacement at Northcroft and 5% contingency for a
grand total of $97,440. The motion was seconded by Board Member Kohlmeyer. The
motion passed.
C. Approval of Tree Planting Contract
City Forester Gordon presented the contract for tree planting for FY ’15. This year, mostly
because of EAB, the plan is to plant approximately 400 trees. Mr. Gordon emphasized that
this was for the planting of the trees only. The City went out to bid through a municipal
partnering program with the City of Highland Park and the Highland Park Park District.
Chairman Volkmann asked if we are comfortable with 400 trees being planted. Mr. Gordon
responded that they were comfortable with maintaining 400 trees, but he did not believe
that was enough trees based on the number of trees that have been removed. Mr. Gordon
also shared that it was never the intent to replace all of the trees that are removed. Mr.
Gordon also shared how the homeowners can participate in the tree choices for their
property if they are having a tree replaced by calling the Forestry section.
Requested Action: Approval of a one-year contract with Nilco, Inc. for the planting of trees
on City streets, parks and City-owned properties for a total of $45,650.
A motion was made by Board Member Jasica to approve a one-year contract with Nilco,
Inc. for the planting of trees on City streets, parks and City-owned properties for a total of
$45,650. The motion was seconded by Board Member Brush. The motion passed.
D. Approval of Tree & Stump Removal Contract
City Forester Gordon presented the contract for tree & stump removal for FY ’15. He
explained that this is an annual contract to include the removal of trees & stumps on City
streets, City owned properties, and unimproved easements. He explained why there was a
need to award this contract to three different vendors as the sheer volume of trees to be
removed due to EAB was too many for one vendor to take on. A conversation followed
regarding how the allocation of the work is between the three (3) vendors, how the disease
is progressing and how the treatment is working.
Requested Action: Approval of a one-year contract with Clean Cut Tree Service, Kinnucan
Tree Experts and Lucas Landscaping and Design in the total amount of $200,000 for FY ’15
tree and stump removal of ash trees on City streets, City-owned properties and unimproved
easements.
A motion was made by Board Member Walker to approve a one-year contract with Clean
Cut Tree Service, Kinnucan Tree Experts and Lucas Landscaping and Design in the total
amount of $200,000 for FY ’15 tree and stump removal of ash trees on City streets, City-
owned properties and unimproved easements. The motion was seconded by Board
Member Kohlmeyer. The motion passed.
E. Approval of Grounds Maintenance Contract
Supervisor Paulsen presented the Grounds Maintenance Contract. He shared the
background of why the City pursued outsourcing the mowing of many of the City’s parcels.
In addition, he explained why the City was looking to enter into a 3-year option on the
contract this year. A conversation followed regarding the difference in the bid pricing.
Requested Action: Approval of a one-year contract with Landscape Concepts in the total
amount of $55,838 for FY ’15 for the grounds maintenance of City properties, cul-de-sacs,
and right-of-ways.
A motion was made by Board Member Jasica to approve a one-year contract with
Landscape Concepts in the total amount of $55,838 for FY ’15 for the grounds maintenance
of City properties, cul-de-sacs, and right-of-ways. The motion was seconded by Board
Member Brush. The motion passed.
F. Approval of City Vending Services Contract
Program Manager Mobile presented the Vending Services Contract. He gave an overview of
the vending contract including the locations that have vending machines, Rec Center,
CROYA, the beach, some park pavilions and the west train station. He explained that the
vending service is a revenue line item in the budget, there is no expense to the Rec Center.
Requested Action: Approval of a two-year independent agreement with Mark Vend
Company to provide food and beverage vending service for the Recreation Department,
CROYA and the Office of the City Manager.
A motion was made by Board Member Jasica to approve a two-year independent
agreement with Mark Vend Company to provide food and beverage vending service for
the Recreation Department, CROYA and the Office of the City Manager. The motion was
seconded by Board Member Walker. The motion passed.
G. Approval of Fitness Center Treadmill Contract
Fitness Center Manager Busdeker presented the Fitness Center Treadmill purchase. He
explained that this is for the purchase of four treadmills and is part of a scheduled annual
replacement plan and is budgeted in the City’s Capital fund. In response to Board member
questions regarding so few bidders, Manager Busdeker explained that not all vendors can
meet the specification requirements for the specialty incline treadmill.
Requested Action: Approval of the purchase of four (4) treadmills for the total purchase
price of $27,480 and a trade-in value of $2,100 for a grand total of $25,380.
A motion was made by Board Member Brush to approve the purchase of four (4)
treadmills for the total purchase price of $27,480 and a trade-in value of $2,100 for a
grand total of $25,380. The motion was seconded by Board Member Kohlmeyer. The
motion passed.
VII. Director’s Report
Director Van Arsdale gave an overview of upcoming events.
A. Easter Egg Hunt and Magic Show – April 12th
B. Smelt-O-Rama – April 26th at the Beach
Board Member Kohlmeyer asked about Reptile Rampage this year. Director Van Arsdale gave an
overview of how the event went.
VIII. Comments by Board Members
No comments.
IX. Adjournment
Board Member Jasica moved to adjourn the meeting. Board Member Walker seconded. The
meeting was adjourned at 7:53 p.m.
Respectfully Submitted
Tricia Schwall
Administrative Assistant
IV. FOREST PARK PROJECT UPDATE
Members of the Forest Park Project and Construction Team will attend the meeting to provide the Parks
and Recreation Board with an update on the construction timeline that was revised in light of the
impacts from the harsh winter and recent spring weather challenges. They will review the enclosed
timeline in more detail, the background on the required sequencing of work, and its impact upon public
access through Fall 2014.
The attached proposed timeline, titled Your Park-Forest Park, is a draft of what will be enlarged to
create signs that will be placed at the park and beach this summer.
West Path - BeforeAfterRing Road - BeforeAfterBluff Walk- BeforeAfterVista - BeforeAfter YOUR PARK - FOREST PARK 2014 For more info and to support your park visit www.ForestParkProject.comSouth Parking - BeforeAfterCompleted by June 15 ([FDYDWLRQEDVHZRUNDQGFXUELQJIRUQRUWKDQGHDVWSDWK /D\RXWEHQFKIRXQGDWLRQORFDWLRQVDQGSRXUEDVHV 6HHGDQGSODQWGH¿QHGDUHDV 5,1*52$'23(121:((.(1'621/< %(/9('(5(67$,56$&&(663529,'(' :(673$7+23(16Completed by July 15 ([FDYDWHDQGLQVWDOOEDVHIRUHDVWSDWKFRQWLQXLQJVRXWK 3ODQWGH¿QHGDUHDV 5,1*52$'23(121:((.(1'621/< %(/9('(5(67$,56$&&(663529,'(' :(673$7+23(1Completed by August 15 3DWKZRUNFRQWLQXHVWRVRXWK ,QVWDOOOLJKWHGEROODUGVDORQJVRXWKSDWK ,QVWDOOERDUGZDONWKURXJKZRRGHGDUHD 5,1*52$'23(121:((.(1'621/< %(/9('(5(67$,56$&&(663529,'(' :(673$7+23(1 3$57,$/($673$7+23(16Completed by Sept. 1 ,QVWDOOSDWKZD\VVRXWKRIORW ,QVWDOOSODQWLQJVVRXWKRIORW )LQLVK6RXWKSDUNLQJORW 5,1*52$')8//<23(1(' %(/9('(5(67$,56$&&(663529,'(' :(67($67 %2$5':$/.3$7+623(1Completed After Sept. 1 5HPRYHJUDQXODULQVWDOOVWRQHSDYLQJRQSDWKWKDWFRQQHFWV/DNH5RDGWR%HOYHGHUHVWDLUV ,QVWDOOVWRQHSDYLQJDW%HOYHGHUHODQGLQJDQG6RXWKSDUNLQJORW )LQDOOLIWRIDVSKDOWIRU5LQJ5RDG6RXWKSDUNLQJORW ,QVWDOODOODPHQLWLHVDQGSDUNSHUPDQHQWVLJQDJH 5,1*52$'&/26(':+(13$9,1*2&&856 %(/9('(5(67$,5$&&(663529,'(' 3$7+67+528*+2873$5.23(1Weather permitting - proposed timelineREHABILITATE ENHANCE PRESERVE
5/16/2014
1
BEACH AND BASIN 2014
PARK BOARD SPOTLIGHT
MAY 20, 2014
BEACH
SEASON
HOURS OF OPERATION
WHAT ARE “CELLS”?
BEACH CLOSURES
5/16/2014
2
BASIN
SEASON
HOURS OF OPERATION
STORAGE OPTIONS
NON‐RESIDENT LAUNCHING
WHAT TO DO AT THE BEACH?
WATERCRAFT USAGE PROGRAM
SPECIAL EVENTS
FITNESS CLASSES
RAGING KITCHEN
5/16/2014
3
CHALLENGES FOR 2014
PARKING
PAVILION RENTALS
ATTENDANCE
FY2012
SUMMER
2011
FY2013
SUMMER
2012
FY2014
SUMMER
2013
BEACH –R 78,762 83,790 63,237
BEACH –NR 1,852 6,455 4,822
BASIN 657 1,029 953
TOTAL 81,271 91,274 69,012
5/16/2014
4
FINANCIALS
FY2012
SUMMER 2011
FY2013
SUMMER 2012
FY2014
SUMMER 2013
(UNAUDITED)
REVENUE EXPENSES REVENUE EXPENSES REVENUE EXPENSES
RECREATION 118,679 148,860 159,988 150,685 137,738 133,620
PARK
MAINTENANCE 27,000 36,000 32,000
TOTAL 118,679 175,860 159,988 186,685 137,738 165,620
Tax Dollar
Support (57,181) (26,697) (54,579)
QUESTIONS?
SEE YOU AT
THE BEACH!
SUBJECT: Award Contract for Fitness Center Weight Equipment Purchase as Included
in the FY15 Capital Plan
PRESENTED BY: FITNESS CENTER MANAGER, JASON R. BUSDEKER 810-3934
PURPOSE AND ACTION REQUESTED: Staff requests approval to purchase 19 selectorized
weight machines, 5 Free weight machines and 1 multi-station unit. This purchase is part
of a scheduled annual replacement plan and is budgeted in the City’s FY15 Capital
Fund. This capital purchase had been deferred from the FY14 Capital Plan.
BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION: This purchase will replace current weight equipment that
has reached the end of their useful life. With continued use, the likelihood of increase
maintenance costs and possible safety hazards become greater. Outdated equipment
also negatively impacts revenue potential. Public notice to solicit bids was provided on
April 24, 2014 with a bid opening date of May 9, 2014. In addition to public notices, bid
packets were delivered to the two equipment vendors in the area. Staff received three
(3) bids for the weight equipment purchase. Staff will trade in nineteen (19) selectorized
weight machines, five free weight machines and one (1) multi-station unit to help offset
the cost of the new equipment.
Bid results were as follows.
Purchase Price Trade-In Total
LifeFitness $29,754.00 $6,100.00 $23,733.00
(13 pieces of equipment)
Direct Fitness Solutions $45,422.20 $7,050.00 $38,812.80
(11 pieces of equipment)
Promaxima* Disqualified
*Did not fully meet bid specifications
Staff recommends partially awarding the purchase of the weight equipment to Direct
Fitness Solutions and to LifeFitness. Each vendor provided an individual bid for each
piece of equipment. Staff is recommending purchasing the individual piece of
equipment that best meets the specification. In some cases, a bid didn’t meet
specifications and for five(5) pieces, staff chose the equipment that best met the bid
specifications but was not the lowest bid.
BUDGET/FISCAL IMPACT:
FY2014 Funding Source Amount
Budgeted
Amount
Requested
Budgeted?
Y/N
CAPITAL FUND 311 $105,000.00 $62,545.80 Y
PARK BOARD ACTION: Recommend to City Council the award of contract to Lif Fitness
for $23,733.00 and Direct Fitness Solutions for $38,812.80 for a total expenditure of
$62,545.80 for the purchase of fitness equipment as budgeted in the FY15 Capital Plan.
VII. EVERETT TOT LOT PLAYGROUND DESIGN OPTIONS: (no packet materials included)
Staff is still working with the playground designer on preparing the design options and cost
considerations. Staff will forward the draft design proposals in advance of the meeting if possible. Staff
is not seeking approval of the playground project but is seeking feedback from the board on the design
features so that we may bring the project back to the board as an action item at the COTW June 17th
meeting, which would be noted as such on the June public agenda. This project was budgeted in the
FY15 Capital Plan.
VIII. CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECT UPDATE: (no packet materials included)
Superintendent Myers will provide a verbal report on the status of our other FY15 Park-related Capital
projects including the McClory Bike Trail, Northcroft and Deerpath Tennis Courts, and Deerpath Walking
Path. In addition, Superintendent Myers will demonstrate a new construction mapping feature now
available on our website to help keep residents up-to-date on construction projects throughout the City.